3720-3720: Verify the MetricInterceptor implementation and existing configurations

The schema changes consistently add "MetricInterceptor" as a valid option across all gRPC client interceptor definitions. While the change itself is well-structured, we should verify a few things:

1. The implementation of MetricInterceptor exists and is ready for use
2. The impact on existing configurations that may need to be updated

Let's verify the implementation and usage:

Also applies to: 7056-7059, 7419-7419, 7771-7774, 9651-9654, 10002-10005, 10354-10357, 12240-12240, 14296-14299, 14647-14650, 15013-15013, 16708-16711, 17059-17062, 18760-18763, 19111-19114, 22491-22494, 22842-22845

#!/bin/bash
# Check for MetricInterceptor implementation
echo "Searching for MetricInterceptor implementation..."
rg -t go "type MetricInterceptor" -l

# Check for existing usage in configurations
echo "Checking existing configurations..."
rg -t yaml "interceptors:" -A 5 "charts/"

#!/bin/bash
# Let's search for the MetricInterceptor implementation in Go files
echo "Searching for MetricInterceptor implementation and usage..."
rg -t go "MetricInterceptor" -A 5

# Also check for any recent changes related to MetricInterceptor
echo "Checking recent changes..."
git log -n 5 --oneline --grep="MetricInterceptor"

69-72: LGTM: Improved type constraints for dataset properties.

The explicit type definitions and constraints for group and indexes properties enhance schema validation.

97-102: LGTM: Enhanced type definitions for dataset and jobs.

The explicit type definitions for dataset and jobs properties improve schema clarity.

107-115: LGTM: Improved target configuration constraints.

The addition of constraints for host and port properties enhances validation:

• host requires minimum length of 1
• port is properly bounded between 0 and 65535

77-89: Consider removing the enum constraint for the dataset name.

The name property's enum constraint has been removed, making it more flexible. However, ensure this change is intentional and won't break existing implementations that rely on specific dataset names.

167-170: LGTM: Enhanced gRPC client interceptor configuration.

Added support for MetricInterceptor alongside TraceInterceptor in the client configuration.

704-712: LGTM: Comprehensive gRPC server interceptor configuration.

Added support for multiple interceptors with clear enumeration:

• RecoverInterceptor
• AccessLogInterceptor
• TraceInterceptor
• MetricInterceptor

167-170: LGTM: Consistent schema definitions with CRD.

The values schema correctly mirrors the CRD changes for interceptor configurations:

1. Client interceptors: TraceInterceptor, MetricInterceptor
2. Server interceptors: RecoverInterceptor, AccessLogInterceptor, TraceInterceptor, MetricInterceptor

Also applies to: 704-712

141-144: LGTM: Interceptors configuration enhanced

The addition of MetricInterceptor to the allowed interceptors aligns with the gRPC client interceptor updates mentioned in the PR summary.

248-281: LGTM: Comprehensive dataset validation

The dataset configuration includes:

• Proper validation for group names (minLength: 1)
• Valid range checks for indexes
• Enum validation for dataset names
• Required field validation

Line range hint 379-602: LGTM: Well-structured health check configurations

The health check configurations (liveness, readiness, startup) follow Kubernetes best practices with:

• Proper port range validation
• Complete probe configurations
• Appropriate HTTP endpoint settings

Line range hint 1-823: LGTM: Well-structured and comprehensive CRD schema

The CRD schema is well-defined with:

• Proper type definitions for all fields
• Comprehensive validation rules
• Appropriate constraints for numeric values
• Clear enum definitions
• Required field specifications

The changes align with the PR objective of updating dependencies and follow Kubernetes best practices.

Line range hint 1-1: LGTM - Routine dependency updates

The dependency updates are minor version or patch version changes, suggesting routine maintenance and bug fixes. The verification scripts will help confirm there are no breaking changes or security implications.

134-134: Verify go-json update compatibility

The update from v0.10.3 to v0.10.4 is a patch version change for this critical JSON handling library.

#!/bin/bash
# Description: Check changelog and release notes for breaking changes

# Check the release notes
gh api repos/goccy/go-json/releases/tags/v0.10.4 --jq '.body'

# Check for any security advisories
gh api graphql -f query='
{
  securityVulnerabilities(first: 5, ecosystem: GO, package: "github.com/goccy/go-json") {
    nodes {
      advisory {
        summary
        severity
        publishedAt
      }
      vulnerableVersionRange
      firstPatchedVersion {
        identifier
      }
    }
  }
}'

39-39: Verify cloudsql-proxy update compatibility

The update from v1.37.2 to v1.37.3 is a patch version change.

#!/bin/bash
# Description: Check changelog and release notes for breaking changes

# Check the release notes
gh api repos/GoogleCloudPlatform/cloudsql-proxy/releases/tags/v1.37.3 --jq '.body'

# Check for any security advisories
gh api graphql -f query='
{
  securityVulnerabilities(first: 5, ecosystem: GO, package: "github.com/GoogleCloudPlatform/cloudsql-proxy") {
    nodes {
      advisory {
        summary
        severity
        publishedAt
      }
      vulnerableVersionRange
      firstPatchedVersion {
        identifier
      }
    }
  }
}'

3720-3720: Verify impact on existing configurations

The addition of "MetricInterceptor" to the enum should be backward compatible, but let's verify existing configurations won't be affected.

Also applies to: 7056-7059, 7419-7419, 7771-7774, 9651-9654, 10002-10005, 10354-10357, 12240-12240, 14296-14299, 14647-14650, 15013-15013, 16708-16711, 17059-17062, 18760-18763, 19111-19114, 22491-22494, 22842-22845

#!/bin/bash
# Search for existing interceptor configurations in Helm values files
echo "Searching for existing interceptor configurations..."
fd -e yaml -e values.yaml | xargs rg "interceptors:"

# Search for TraceInterceptor usage in values files
echo "Searching for TraceInterceptor usage..."
fd -e yaml -e values.yaml | xargs rg "TraceInterceptor"

3720-3720: Verify the MetricInterceptor implementation

The schema now includes "MetricInterceptor" alongside "TraceInterceptor" across all gRPC client interceptor configurations. Let's verify the implementation exists.

Also applies to: 7056-7059, 7419-7419, 7771-7774, 9651-9654, 10002-10005, 10354-10357, 12240-12240, 14296-14299, 14647-14650, 15013-15013, 16708-16711, 17059-17062, 18760-18763, 19111-19114, 22491-22494, 22842-22845

#!/bin/bash
# Search for MetricInterceptor implementation
echo "Searching for MetricInterceptor implementation..."
rg -t go "type MetricInterceptor" -A 5

# Search for MetricInterceptor usage in Go files
echo "Searching for MetricInterceptor usage..."
rg -t go "MetricInterceptor"

# Search for related metrics configuration
echo "Searching for metrics configuration..."
fd -e yaml -e json | xargs rg "metrics?"

#!/bin/bash
# Check metric interceptor implementations
echo "Checking client metric interceptor implementation..."
rg -t go -A 10 "func ClientMetricInterceptors" internal/net/grpc/interceptor/client/metric/

echo "Checking server metric interceptor implementation..."
rg -t go -A 10 "func MetricInterceptors" internal/net/grpc/interceptor/server/metric/

69-97: LGTM: Dataset schema improvements enhance validation.

The dataset property schema has been properly structured with:

• Explicit type definitions
• Appropriate minimum constraints for numeric fields
• Clear required field specifications

98-102: LGTM: Jobs array schema maintains flexibility.

The jobs array schema correctly:

• Defines items as objects
• Preserves unknown fields for extensibility

103-115: LGTM: Target schema properly constrains network configuration.

The target property schema appropriately:

• Enforces minimum length for host
• Constrains port within valid range (0-65535)
• Specifies required fields

608-614: LGTM: gRPC interceptor types properly expanded.

The interceptors enum has been appropriately updated to include all required types:

• RecoverInterceptor
• AccessLogInterceptor
• TraceInterceptor
• MetricInterceptor

This aligns with the changes in values.schema.json.

167-170: LGTM: Client interceptor configuration properly updated.

The client interceptors enum correctly includes:

• TraceInterceptor
• MetricInterceptor

704-712: LGTM: Server interceptor configuration properly updated.

The server interceptors enum correctly includes all required types:

• RecoverInterceptor
• AccessLogInterceptor
• TraceInterceptor
• MetricInterceptor

167-170: Verify consistency of interceptor configurations across the codebase.

Let's ensure the interceptor configurations are consistent across all related files.

Also applies to: 704-712

#!/bin/bash
# Description: Check consistency of interceptor configurations across the codebase

# Search for interceptor configurations in yaml and json files
echo "Checking interceptor configurations in yaml and json files..."
rg -U --type yaml --type json 'interceptors:(\s+|\n+)-.*Interceptor' -A 5

#!/bin/bash
# Check schema definitions and benchmark operator configurations
echo "Checking schema and benchmark operator configurations..."

# Search for TraceInterceptor and MetricInterceptor in schema files
echo "=== Schema definitions ==="
rg -U --type json --type yaml "TraceInterceptor|MetricInterceptor" charts/vald-benchmark-operator/

# Search for benchmark scenario configurations
echo -e "\n=== Benchmark scenario configurations ==="
rg -U --type yaml "kind:\s+ValdbenchmarkScenario" -A 10

257-272: Dataset range validation looks good

The schema properly enforces:

• Valid dataset names (original, fashion-mnist)
• Required start and end range values
• Minimum value validation for indexes

Line range hint 1-823: Verify schema compatibility with existing configurations

The schema changes look comprehensive and well-structured. However, we should verify compatibility with existing ValdBenchmarkJob configurations.

#!/bin/bash
# Find and validate existing ValdBenchmarkJob configurations
echo "Checking existing configurations..."
find_cmd="fd -e yaml -e yml"

# Look for existing benchmark job configurations
$find_cmd | while read -r file; do
  if grep -l "kind: ValdBenchmarkJob" "$file" > /dev/null; then
    echo "Found benchmark job config: $file"
    # Check for potentially incompatible fields
    grep -A2 "interceptors:" "$file" || true
    grep -A2 "dataset:" "$file" || true
  fi
done

142-144: New gRPC interceptors added

The addition of TraceInterceptor and MetricInterceptor enhances observability. Ensure that these interceptors are implemented and available in the codebase.

#!/bin/bash
# Check if the interceptors are implemented
ast-grep --pattern 'type $interceptor struct {
  $$$
}' | grep -E "Trace.*Interceptor|Metric.*Interceptor"

# Verify interceptor usage in existing configurations
rg -l "TraceInterceptor|MetricInterceptor" -g "*.yaml" -g "*.yml"

#!/bin/bash
# Search for interceptor implementations in Go files
rg -A 5 "type.*(Trace|Metric).*Interceptor" --type go

# Search for interceptor registration or usage in Go files
rg -A 5 "(New|With)(Trace|Metric).*Interceptor" --type go

#!/bin/bash
# Search for any mentions of these interceptors in Go files
rg -B 2 -A 2 "TraceInterceptor|MetricInterceptor" --type go

# Look for any interceptor-related packages or imports
rg -l "interceptor" --type go | grep -i "trace\|metric"

39-39: Verify the changelog for cloudsql-proxy update

The update from v1.37.2 to v1.37.3 is a patch version increment that likely contains bug fixes or security patches.

#!/bin/bash
# Description: Check the changelog and release notes for cloudsql-proxy v1.37.3

# Fetch release notes for the new version
gh api repos/GoogleCloudPlatform/cloudsql-proxy/releases/tags/v1.37.3 --jq '.body'

# Check for any security advisories
gh api graphql -f query='
{
  securityVulnerabilities(first: 5, ecosystem: GO, package: "github.com/GoogleCloudPlatform/cloudsql-proxy") {
    nodes {
      advisory {
        summary
        severity
        publishedAt
      }
      vulnerableVersionRange
      firstPatchedVersion {
        identifier
      }
    }
  }
}'

134-134: Verify the changelog for go-json update

The update from v0.10.3 to v0.10.4 is a patch version increment that likely contains bug fixes or performance improvements.

#!/bin/bash
# Description: Check the changelog and release notes for go-json v0.10.4

# Fetch release notes for the new version
gh api repos/goccy/go-json/releases/tags/v0.10.4 --jq '.body'

# Check for any security advisories
gh api graphql -f query='
{
  securityVulnerabilities(first: 5, ecosystem: GO, package: "github.com/goccy/go-json") {
    nodes {
      advisory {
        summary
        severity
        publishedAt
      }
      vulnerableVersionRange
      firstPatchedVersion {
        identifier
      }
    }
  }
}'

Line range hint 1-600: Verify dependency compatibility

The version updates appear to be backward compatible based on semantic versioning. However, it's good practice to verify the changes don't introduce any breaking changes.

#!/bin/bash
# Description: Check for potential compatibility issues

# Look for any go.mod files that might have compatibility requirements
fd -e mod -x rg -l "github.com/GoogleCloudPlatform/cloudsql-proxy|github.com/goccy/go-json|golang.org/x/crypto" {}

# Check for any existing issues related to these dependencies
rg "cloudsql-proxy|go-json|golang.org/x/crypto" -g "!{go.mod,go.sum}"

#!/bin/bash
# Check for specific version constraints and usage patterns

# Check for any direct imports of these packages in the codebase
ast-grep --pattern 'import "$_"' | rg "cloudsql-proxy|go-json|golang.org/x/crypto"

# Look for any version-specific API usage
rg -A 3 -B 3 "json\.(Marshal|Unmarshal|NewEncoder|NewDecoder)" internal/encoding/json/json.go

# Check for any custom configuration or initialization of these packages
rg -A 5 "func init\(\)" internal/encoding/json/json.go

3720-3720: Schema changes look good, verify implementation and documentation.

The addition of "MetricInterceptor" to the gRPC client interceptors enum is consistent across all locations. This non-breaking change enables metric collection capabilities for gRPC clients.

Let's verify the corresponding implementation and documentation:

Also applies to: 7056-7059, 7419-7419, 7771-7774, 9651-9654, 10002-10005, 10354-10357, 12240-12240, 14296-14299, 14647-14650, 15013-15013, 16708-16711, 17059-17062, 18760-18763, 19111-19114, 22491-22494, 22842-22845

#!/bin/bash
# Description: Check for metric interceptor implementation and documentation

# Check for metric interceptor implementation
echo "Checking for MetricInterceptor implementation..."
rg -t go "type MetricInterceptor" -l
rg -t go "func.*MetricInterceptor" -l

# Check for documentation updates needed
echo "Checking documentation for interceptor references..."
fd -t f . docs -e md -e rst | xargs rg -l "interceptor"

#!/bin/bash
# Let's check the implementation details and documentation content

# Check the metric interceptor implementation
echo "=== Metric Interceptor Implementation ==="
ast-grep --pattern 'type MetricInterceptor struct {
  $$$
}'

# Check the documentation content for interceptor references
echo -e "\n=== Documentation Content ==="
cat docs/user-guides/observability-configuration.md | grep -A 5 -B 5 "interceptor"

69-116: LGTM! Schema validation improvements enhance data integrity.

The changes strengthen the CRD schema by:

• Adding explicit type definitions
• Setting appropriate constraints (e.g., minimum values, string lengths)
• Defining required fields
• Adding proper validation for port ranges (0-65535)

These improvements will help catch configuration errors early and ensure data consistency.

704-712: LGTM! Enhanced interceptor configuration with new types.

The addition of new interceptor types (RecoverInterceptor, AccessLogInterceptor, TraceInterceptor, MetricInterceptor) improves observability and error handling capabilities.

Let's verify the implementation of these interceptors:

#!/bin/bash
# Description: Verify the implementation of the new interceptors

# Check for interceptor implementations
echo "Checking for interceptor implementations..."
rg -g "*.go" -A 5 "type.*Interceptor.*struct"

# Check for interceptor usage
echo "Checking for interceptor usage..."
rg -g "*.go" -A 5 "New.*Interceptor"

#!/bin/bash
# Search for specific interceptor types mentioned in the CRD
echo "Searching for RecoverInterceptor..."
rg -g "*.go" -B 2 -A 5 "RecoverInterceptor"

echo -e "\nSearching for AccessLogInterceptor..."
rg -g "*.go" -B 2 -A 5 "AccessLogInterceptor"

echo -e "\nSearching for TraceInterceptor..."
rg -g "*.go" -B 2 -A 5 "TraceInterceptor"

echo -e "\nSearching for MetricInterceptor..."
rg -g "*.go" -B 2 -A 5 "MetricInterceptor"

# Search in the CRD file to see the complete interceptor configuration
echo -e "\nChecking CRD interceptor configuration..."
grep -A 10 "interceptors:" k8s/tools/benchmark/operator/crds/valdbenchmarkoperatorrelease.yaml

167-170: LGTM! Client interceptor configuration enhanced.

The addition of MetricInterceptor to client interceptors aligns with the observability improvements.

704-712: LGTM! Server interceptor configuration is comprehensive.

The server interceptor configuration now includes a complete set of interceptors:

• RecoverInterceptor for error handling
• AccessLogInterceptor for request logging
• TraceInterceptor for distributed tracing
• MetricInterceptor for metrics collection

Line range hint 316-347: LGTM! Well-structured job configuration

The job configuration includes:

• Comprehensive set of operation types
• Proper range validations for numeric fields
• Clear separation of concerns

Line range hint 1-823: Verify CRD compatibility with existing deployments

The CRD includes significant schema enhancements. Please ensure backward compatibility with existing ValdBenchmarkJob resources.

#!/bin/bash
# Check for existing ValdBenchmarkJob resources that might be affected
kubectl get valdbenchmarkjobs -A -o json | jq -r '.items[] | select(.spec | keys - ["client_config","dataset","global_config","job_type","object_config","remove_config","repetition","replica","rps","rules","search_config","server_config","target","ttl_seconds_after_finished","update_config","upsert_config"] | length > 0) | .metadata.namespace + "/" + .metadata.name'

#!/bin/bash
# Let's verify the CRD changes by checking git history for any breaking changes
git log -p --no-merges k8s/tools/benchmark/operator/crds/valdbenchmarkjob.yaml | grep -A 5 -B 5 "^[-+].*spec:"

# Also check for any references to this CRD in other files
rg -l "valdbenchmarkjob" --type yaml

#!/bin/bash
# Let's check the content of related files to verify CRD usage
cat k8s/tools/benchmark/job/clusterrole.yaml k8s/tools/benchmark/operator/clusterrole.yaml

# Also check if there are any example resources using this CRD
fd -e yaml -e yml . | xargs grep -l "kind: ValdBenchmarkJob"

#!/bin/bash
# Let's check example resources to understand the usage pattern
cat example/helm/benchmark/job-values.yaml charts/vald-benchmark-operator/values/benchmark-job.yaml

# Also check if there are any differences between the CRD in charts and k8s directories
diff k8s/tools/benchmark/operator/crds/valdbenchmarkjob.yaml charts/vald-benchmark-operator/crds/valdbenchmarkjob.yaml

Line range hint 74-241: LGTM! Comprehensive type definitions enhance schema validation.

The client configuration schema has been well-structured with proper type definitions, constraints, and enums. This improves type safety and provides better validation for:

• Network configuration options
• Connection pool settings
• Circuit breaker parameters
• TLS configuration

Line range hint 677-712: LGTM! Well-defined service configuration schema.

The service configuration schema properly defines:

• Valid service types (ClusterIP, LoadBalancer, NodePort)
• External traffic policy support
• Service annotations and labels

Line range hint 309-378: LGTM! Comprehensive job configuration schema.

The job configuration schema properly defines:

• Valid job types (insert, update, upsert, search, remove, getobject, exists)
• Search configuration with proper algorithm options
• Numeric constraints for search parameters

Line range hint 378-602: LGTM! Well-structured health check configuration schema.

The health check configuration schema properly defines:

• Liveness, readiness, and startup probe configurations
• HTTP server settings with proper timeout configurations
• Port validations and server modes

278-288: Coordinated update of OpenTelemetry components

All OpenTelemetry components have been updated to consistent versions:

• Core components updated to v1.33.0
• gRPC instrumentation updated to v0.58.0

This coordinated update ensures compatibility across the OpenTelemetry ecosystem.

352-352: Version alignment with hack/go.mod.default template

The cloud.google.com/go/storage v1.47.0 version aligns with the pinned version in hack/go.mod.default, maintaining consistency across the codebase.

Also applies to: 427-427

322-322: Verify compatibility with updated gRPC and Protobuf versions

Significant version updates detected:

• gRPC: v1.69.2
• Protobuf: v1.36.0

These major version jumps may include breaking changes.

Also applies to: 324-324

2309-2310: LGTM: Method signature updates are consistent

The test cases have been properly updated to include the new poolSize parameter for Insert and Bulk operations.

Also applies to: 2902-2902

2309-2310: LGTM! Appropriate poolSize value for single vector insertion.

The poolSize parameter is correctly added with a value of 1, which is appropriate for single vector insertions.

Line range hint 3192-3339: LGTM! Appropriate poolSize value for index creation tests.

The poolSize parameter is correctly added with a value of 1. This is reasonable for these test cases as they focus on verifying index creation behavior rather than insertion performance.